The Whale
AlthoughThe Whaleis being hailed as the comeback film for actor Brendan Fraser , Darren Aronofsky ’s film is garnering contestation owing to concerns because ofThe Whalefatphobia tilt . The Whaletells the story of sequestered English teacher Charlie ( Brendan Fraser ) who is living with severe fleshiness and attempts to reconnect with his estranged teenage daughter , Ellie ( Sadie Sink ) , one last time . The Whalerepresents the first leading feature film role for Brendan Fraser in virtually a decade ; he has been working in mostly plump for parts , such as Steven Soderbergh’sNo Sudden Move , and television roles such asDoom Patrol ’s Cliff Steele . The Whaleis also the eighth feature article picture show from director Darren Aronofsky , whose movies such as 2000’sRequiem for a Dreamand 2017’smother ! , often receive themselves at the plaza of argument for their often graphical content and raise up themes .
Despite almost universal praise forBrendan Fraser ’s transformative central performance , Aronofsky ’s latest motion-picture show is once again the center of attention ofThe Whalefatphobia argument . The Whalebegan attracting controversy upon the announcement of the film ’s premise , and concerns about the movie ’s fatphobia only increased after its premiere at the 79th Venice International Film Festival in September 2022 . Many of the accusations of fatphobia take aim at Aronofsky ’s enjoyment of a fatsuit to help portray Fraser ’s Charlie as a 600 lb man , as well as the film ’s plain trivial treatment of corpulency . One constant brilliant spot surroundingThe Whale ’s more controversial scene , however , is Brendan Fraser ’s performance as Charlie , which is systematically pertain to as empathic , compassionate , and imbued with humanity in review article for the pic .
Related : How Brendan Fraser Almost pall In The Mummy ( For Real )
The Whale Is Being Celebrated For Brendan Fraser’s Comeback Performance
Part of the cause thatThe Whaleis being celebrated asBrendan Fraser ’s rejoinder performanceis that it ’s his first major pic role in almost a decennary , and Fraser make water the most of this opportunity to truly captivate the humankind of his case . DespiteThe Whalefatphobia contention , Fraser imbues Charlie with a simultaneous sentience of affectionateness and guilt trip , completely obviate handle him as an exploitatory , morbid spectacle , despite both the type ’s size and the amount of both practical and digital outcome used inThe Whaleto portray him . In herreview ofThe Whale , ScreenRant ’s own Mae Abdulbaki praise Fraser ’s functioning as " magnetic and nuanced . " The success of Fraser ’s performance is not only apparent in many of the reviews of the film , but was also clear on display atThe Whale ’s Toronto International Film Festival ( TIFF ) premiere . Fraser received a five - minute of arc standing ovationat TIFF ’s testify ofThe Whale , which brought the actor to tear , before he tell the crowd that he hop the film would " commute some hearts and minds " and would inspire more compassion among viewers .
The Whale’s Fatphobia Controversy Explained
Despite the almost ecumenical praise for Brendan Fraser ’s human performance , as well as the acting from the rest of the moving-picture show ’s ensemble , The Whalehas collect a lot of tilt for the film ’s supposed fatphobia from viewers and critic likewise . The Whalefatphobia controversy has partially stemmed from the use of a fatsuit to make Brendan Fraser attend like he weigh the 600 lb that his character does , rather than hiring an role player of a similar bod to Charlie . The fatsuit was then digitally altered in post - yield to further increase the sizing of the case to the full 600 pound . Critics of this creative conclusion bydirector Darren Aronofskyclaim that this choice undercut Fraser ’s human performance and plow Charlie in a voyeuristical manner .
Aronofsky ’s direction has been further criticized as stress the cruelty that Charlie endure , especially the verbal abuse that Charlie receives from his girl Ellie , and treats his eating as a dreaded spectacle , that seems at odds with the empathy that Fraser ’s public presentation achieves . The Whale ’s sound admixture emphasizes the uncomfortable noises of eat during any scene where Charlie has food for thought , while downbeat music play to further set the nervous atmosphere . Darren Aronofsky ’s directorial choices do not seem to occur from a topographic point of empathy , and they seem to process Charlie like a circus spectacle rather than the three - dimensional human Brendan Fraser ’s operation does .
The Whale ’s tale has also been accused of using Charlie ’s corpulency purely as a metaphor and set dressing , rather than lock with it at a narrative level . No stranger to religious iconography(Aronofsky ’s previous moving-picture show include the Biblical adaptationNoah ) critics have say that the director seems more concerned in using Charlie as a Christ - alike sacrificial figure rather than a three - dimensional part in his own right hand . The Whalepays lip military service to the poor means that rich the great unwashed are treated in hospitals and other aesculapian configurations . However , the film has been accused ofThe Whalefatphobia controversy by using Charlie ’s refusal to go to the infirmary as a room to show the consultation that he is ego - sacrificial , rather than recognize that studies show that rotund patient are often either dismissed or misdiagnosed by doctors .
Related:1 Legacy Sequel Could Reunite The Rock & Brendan Fraser ( Not The Mummy )
Will The Whale’s Controversy Hurt The Movie?
The old adage goes : " there ’s no such thing as bad publicity , " however , this is not always the case , examine byThe Whalefatphobia controversy . The filmAmsterdam , released in October 2022 open to meaning controversy due to issue surrounding its director , David O. Russell , and take in incrediblypoor boxwood office numbers game . These controversies include the director assaulting fellow director Christopher Nolan at a party back in 2003 , being verbally scurrilous towards role player Lily Tomlin on - readiness , and Russell admitting to sexually abusing his niece . Despite an all - asterisk plaster cast , including Christian Bale , Margot Robbie , and John David Washington , Amsterdamflopped upon its release and is expected to lose 20th Century Studios around $ 100 million . The contestation surroundingThe Whale , although nowhere close as damnatory asAmsterdam , could smart the movie upon its wide release in December 2022 .
Aside from hurting the movie financially , The Whalefatphobia contestation could hurt the picture as an experience for viewers , given that so many of them are tied in with the cognitive content of the movie itself . Many of Darren Aronofsky ’s movies wallow in the misery of their characters , The Whale ’s Charlieincluded . This is most notable in Aronofsky ’s psychological drama about drug addicts , Requiem for a Dream , which treats the dilapidating effects of heroin like a horror movie . These stylistic choices on Aronofsky ’s part have been noted as more than present inThe Whalewith the picture often emphasizing Charlie ’s sizing and eating habit for horror rather than empathy . AlthoughThe Whalecontains a career - best , and deep humanist , public presentation from Brendan Fraser , the more controversial aspects of the film threaten to slump that performance in a ocean of miserableness .
The Whale’s Fatphobia Controversy Didn’t Affect The Academy Awards
The Whalefatphobia controversy away , Brendan Fraser ’s public presentation as Charlie has caught the Academy ’s aid , win three nominations for theupcoming 2023 Oscars . In fact , Aronofsky ’s moving picture receive far-flung critical eclat due to Fraser ’s drastic transformation , being nominated for a Best Makeup and Hairstyling Oscar . However , due toThe Whalefatphobia controversy , it ’s potential that the cinema will be passed up in favor of other contenders likeElvisandThe Batman . Brendan Fraser also , deservedly , scooped up a Best Actor Award nominating address thanks to his humane approaching to the character . This is Fraser ’s first Oscar nominating address ever , but he is going up against other industry veteran such as Colin Farrell ( The Banshees of Inisherin ) , Bill Nighy ( livelihood ) , Austin Butler ( Elvis ) , and Paul Mescal ( Aftersun ) . at long last , actress Hong Chau , who plays Charlie ’s friend and nanny inThe Whale , Liz , is up for a Best Supporting Actress Oscar .
Next : How Hollywood Failed Brendan Fraser ( & Why He merit A Comeback )
