Daredevil
The oldMarvel Televisionshowsaren’t ever going to be reinstate to canyon in theMarvel Cinematic Universe- regardless of fan complaints . When the MCU launched in 2008 , the hope was that everything would be connected . In 2013 , Marvel Televisions first lively - action TV show appeared to be an extension of that promise , withAgents of SHIELDtying into the MCU ’s broader narration - especially in its first season . But as the old age croak , it unfortunately became clear those connexion would only ever be one - means . Now , Marvel Television is defunct , and it ’s generally becoming unmortgaged all their old boob tube shows should really be considered non - canyon .
Understandably , it ’s a huge dashing hopes to a devoted fanbase . This has most lately manifested in a passionate appeal by the team who execute the MCU Wiki [ via Twitter ] , in which they askMarvel Studios to clear up the shows are canyon , and ensure nothing is done to damage them . " I , we , have put so much cultism emotionally into these shows as part of the MCU , " they pen , " watching the show and experiencing and devoting myself to that world , in income tax return receiving one of the few informant of joy in my lifespan as I shared in this domain growing and progressing in all its dimensions . It would really hurt to incur out the idolatry was wasted , misled , wrong all along ; this rarified joyful thing in my life a falsehood . " The missive is a middle - twist one from fans who absolutely loved TV shows likeAgents of SHIELD , and were willing to accept even poorer products such asInhumansandIron Fistbecause they infer the value of the shared universe .
associate : It ’s Time To take Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Is n’t MCU Canon
Is there any chance such appeals will work ? Or has a line been draw in the gumption , one that effectively delete all the oldMarvel Television shows from continuity ? woefully , the evidence is building that the latter is the case . aright now , it really does n’t look as though these Marvel Television telly serial should be debate part of the MCU any longer .
Marvel TV Shows Don’t Fit MCU Canon Anymore
The first few seasons of Marvel’sAgents of SHIELDrejoiced in their connectivity , with major bow revolve around the result ofCaptain America : The Winter SoldierandAvengers : Age of Ultron . regrettably the latter proved rather more contentious than anybody had expected , because manager Joss Whedon chose not to make an explicit nod toAgents of SHIELDin the film , conceive it would be befuddle for viewers who were only conversant with the movies . " As far as I ’m concerned , in this movie , Coulson ’s numb , " Whedon insisted . " If you come back in the continuation and say Coulson ’s alive , it ’s like putting f***ing John Gielgud in the sequel to ' Arthur . ' It matter that he ’s rifle . It ’s a different world now . And you have to run with that . " Shortly after this , a incorporated restructure at Marvel - forced by Disney due to the souring human relationship between Kevin Feige and Marvel ’s cloistered then - CEO Ike Perlmutter - extend to the movie studio being separated from the remainder of Marvel Entertainment . The explicit reference pretty much terminate , withAgents of SHIELDsettling for thematic nod instead , such as the use of Ghost Rider whenDoctor Strangewas about to attain cinemas .
The lack of any direct line of communication between Marvel Studios and Marvel Television would ultimately undermineAgents of SHIELDwhen the serial attempted to splice in toAvengers : Infinity Waras part of the MCU ’s 10 - year day of remembrance celebrations . There is a sense in which Thanos was the true villain of time of year 5 , because those event were driven by an foreign conspiracy who were attempting to take vantage of the Mad Titan ’s impending attack upon Earth ; but , although season 5 ended with explicit nods to Thanos ' arrival in New York , the show never moved on to divvy up with the consequence of his erasing half the living creatures in the universe . agent of SHIELDseasons 6 and 7 ignored Thanos ginger nut , with Marvel Television ’s Jeph Loeb excuse why . " Just await at it from a very hard-nosed seat , which is , what the world looked like post - snap , [ it ] was not something we had seen yet , " he explained . " We were already snap . " And so Marvel wave the job away by propose all the TV appearance were pre - snap , an argument that just did n’t fit with the timeline .
Marvel Television has since been wind down , in part because it was unsufferable for them to contend with the high - budget tv set exhibit cyclosis on Disney+ . Since then , it has become profusely clear Marvel Studios has no interest in keeping an center on elements of canon from the old TV show;WandaVision ’s Darkhold had a different purpose toAgents of SHIELDand shared none of its history , whileLokiavoided any reference to Coulson ’s resurrections . The most shocking , and frankly counterintuitive , was the conclusion not to reference theAgent CarterTV serial publication in aMarvel Legendsvideo , given that series is entirely contained on Disney+ and promote it in that manner could have encouraged further participation with the streaming service . Meanwhile , the accession of a chronological order on Disney+ has added more trouble , because the chronology brokeAgents of SHIELD ’s timeline by switching some of the flick around .
have-to doe with : WandaVision Just Made Every Marvel TV Show Redundant
Marvel Studios President of the United States Kevin Feige is frequently asked questions about canonicity , but he refuses to be draw , presumptively aware make up any views public could potentially be very divisive indeed ( James Gunn is not so loth , insist on societal media that no pre - WandaVisionTV shows are connected ) . But it ’s striking that the MCU does n’t exactly seem to be paying much tending to what has gone before;Marvel ’s What If … ?has draw on many aspect of the broad canon , even explicitly confirming tie - in comics such asFury ’s Big Week , but it notably has n’t done so for anything made by Marvel Television . There ’s a sense in which this is frankly even defective than make an prescribed statement , because when fans address of " canyon , " what they are really imply is that they require the matter they have loved to matter - to " count " for something in the broader story . But that certainly does n’t seem to be the case for Marvel Television products and the MCU .
The Arguments For Marvel TV Shows Being Canon
The fan - petition does attempt to contend the shows were , and should still be , considered canyon . The writers show to many old quotes that suggestAgents of SHIELDwas the first MCU TV series , notWandaVision , and that the TV shows flesh out the stories enjoin on the big screen . But , at inwardness , their plea is an emotional one , repel by the years of investing they have made in the portion out world as a whole . In their panorama , wiping the oldMarvel Television showsfrom canon would be akin to declaring , 29 season into a serial publication , that a massive amount of what preceded it was all just a dream ; in narrative terms , such an glide path would be deeply prejudicious to the total model the MCU operates on .
One of the most authoritative arguments in the orison basically boils down to the fact Marvel Television was practiced than many view , and its strengths should not be overlooked . It was particularly strong in terminus of diversity and representation , frankly putting Marvel Studios to shame ; Marvel ’s first homosexual , Asian , and Latina superheroes all made their launching inAgents of SHIELD , where Chloe Bennet starred as the Asian - American wedge Quake , Runawayswas unafraid to lionize young lesbian superheroes , bothLuke CageandCloak & Daggerhandled issues of racial inequality remarkably well . Erasing these numerous television series from canon effectively wipes out a lot ofdiversity in the MCUat a shot , which is particularly distressing .
Why The MCU Won’t Make Older Marvel TV Shows Canon Again
Ultimately , there are woefully several reasons Marvel Studios is unconvincing to respond to these appeals by hit the older Marvel TV shows weigh again - by not only declaring them canon , but build upon their concepts and traditional knowledge . The centre number is that the MCU is the product of a singular visual sensation , with Kevin Feige as the architect of the film franchise ’s blockbuster winner , as was recognized in 2015 when the studio was pulled out of the blanket Marvel Entertainment grouping and he became chairperson . In contrast , the Marvel Television show were nothing to do with Feige , and there do n’t even seem to have been good communication channel afterMarvel ’s restructure in 2015 . As dependable asAgents of SHIELD , Daredevil , Cloak & Dagger , Runaways , and so on may have been , they do not represent Feige ’s vision . They do n’t fit .
tie in : agent of SHIELD : Every MCU Movie Character Who Appeared
It does n’t assist that , between 2013 and 2020 , there were so many episodes of Marvel TV appearance . Marvel like to give their writers and managing director a lot of freedom when they ’re bring forth substance , and already this posture problem given the sheer amount of capacity that is officially canon ; they ’re not going to anticipate someone to agree out multiple season of a video serial as well as the film just in ordering to assure they get game - points right . WandaVisiondirector Matt Shakman illustrate this whenhe was require aboutWandaVision ’s Darkhold , which was very different to the Book of Sins visualize inAgents of SHIELD . " We did n’t count at the other Darkholds that had been designed , " he notice . " I do n’t know on the dot how it was used in those other show , because I was n’t a regular viewer , but the Darkhold has a cartoon strip origin . Its mythology will continue to be developed . " In truth , Marvel do n’t really seem especially interested in micro - level persistence to the floor the fans often are in the first place , so it ’s not especially surprising they ’re not reference the TV show .
Ironically , though , the interrogative of canonicity may not be quite as important as some fans believe . agent of SHIELDwas not beneficial because it was part of the MCU ; it was good because it was lovingly made , by a grand squad , and it boast skilled worker who grew into their part as the show go on . Indeed , by the time itended , Agents of SHIELD ’s distance from the MCUwas its strong point , because it had built up its own traditional knowledge and mythology , cover everything from time - travel rule ( better and more consistently formulated thanAvengers : Endgame ) to Inhumans , from Kree Monoliths to foreign races . This truth is even more patent with other Marvel Television shows , that never explicitly attempt to tie in to the films in the first place;Daredevilisn’t one of the best superhero television set shows made in the last decade simply because it materialise in the same earth asIron ManandThe Avengers , but because it was well - made in its own right . Canonicity does not equate tone , and a show does not have to be canon to " count . " The Marvel Television shows had a profound effect on democratic culture , meaning many of their concepts and characters will for sure be revisited in the time to come , and if Marvel studio do " soft reboots " they may wellbring back keep actors like Charlie Cox , Chloe Bennet , or Vincent d’Onofrio . This bequest , more than anything else , will demonstrate that these shows affair - whether they are part of theMCUor not .
More : Every MCU TV Show Ranked Worst to Best
