Related
The bookHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsrevealed Petunia Dursley ’s biggest secret , but Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies did n’t touch on any of it . This significantly change the story circumvent the character , making it so that Petunia ’s on - screen personality would contribute lilliputian but the occasional laughable relief . However , the canyon backstory of Harry ’s aunty makes for a far more tangible role — though still not entirely large-hearted . The upcomingHarry PotterHBO reboot has the chance to right background her character , and her secrets , as it promises to explore one account book per season .
In theHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2movie , Harry witnesses some vital moments in his mother , Lily ’s , childhood . Among them was a minor altercation between Petunia and Lily , in which the former screams that her sister is a freak and runs away . This supports Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies ' earlier title in thesetup ofHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stonethat she had been the only one in the Evans phratry to recognise that Lily ’s wizardly talent was nothing to be praised . Instead , it made her a " junkie . " While Harry ’s auntie made the same asseveration in the book , Snape ’s memories in canon contravene this .
Petunia Dursley Had Been Desperate To Go To Hogwarts
While Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies did n’t search this , inHarry Potter , the memory of Lily and Petunia revealed the older sister had once been delighted by Lily ’s magic ( though a little fearful ) . However , when Lily is invited to Hogwarts , Petunia becomes envious . She write to Professor Dumbledore , tap him to take into account her to accompany her sister to school . The headmaster responded kindly to Petunia and inform her in a letter why that was insufferable . When Lily and Snape after found this letter , Petunia became so embarrassed that she lash out and claimed that she would never want to go to a shoal for inverted comma - unquote " freaks . "
The word break Lily ’s spirit , and it was the last the two sisters were show together in Snape ’s computer storage . This moment in the Good Book importantly modify Petunia ’s ostensibly genuine proclamation inHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stonethat she hated Lily . It instead implies that Petunia hate the wizarding world and thaumaturgy not because it disturbed her but because she had been rejected by it . Not only that , but it had taken her sister away — first to Hogwarts , then to a place that denied Petunia . Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies never received this arc , something that the reboot show could potentially admit .
Did Petunia Love Lily (Or Harry)?
Knowing precisely why Petunia hated magic does n’t exempt her treatment of Lily and Harry . By marrying and having Dudley with Vernon Dursley , a humans who despised anything out of the ordinary , Petunia was rise up as far as she could from the wizarding world . When her baby die prior to the events ofHarry Potter , she was forced to acknowledge that her living was n’t normal and that she ’d have to count after her nephew . The wizarding world and Petunia ’s young lifetime collided , and Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies was stick in the middle .
Very probably did Petunia love Lily inHarry Potter , but her finding to be normal for her husband led her to abuse and neglect her nephew . Harry became a symbol of the wizarding world and everything Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies hated , but she should have recognized that this was n’t the fault of an impeccant child . By cover Harry so poorly , she was burying anything that might have been go out of her love for either of them . It made her one of the most slimy character reference by theending ofDeathly Hallows — even worse than her husband .
Why Harry Potter Skipped Petunia’s Story
The understructure for Petunia ’s big Revelation of Saint John the Divine is subtly laid out throughout the books , with theHarry Potterreboot hopefully pay more attention to it . InOrder of the Phoenix , Petunia surprise Harry by revealing that she know what Dementors are . When he tells her that Voldemort is back , they deal their first facial expression of understanding , and Harry realizes that Lily ’s decease had sham her . InHalf - Blood Prince , Dumbledore introduce himself to Petunia and reminds her that they had once corresponded . Of of course , Aunt Petunia in theHarry Pottermovies did n’t do any of these things , so Petunia ’s reveal would not have had the same impact were it included .
Severus Snape ’s memory board were packed with earth - shaking revelations . The new information that Snape and Lily had been childhood undecomposed friend and thatDumbledore had been raising Harry to dieleft trivial time for more minor divulgences . While Petunia ’s full floor added importantly more deepness to her fiber in the Holy Writ , it did n’t regard the game ofHarry Potter , something the reboot show should rectify . Really , whether Petunia had a honorable reason to detest the wizarding world or not , it did n’t convert the fact that she was horrifying to Harry — which was her most significant theatrical role trait , as far as the plot is touch on .
