Related
Hailed as " the bestStar Warsmovie in years , " Kavan Cardoza ’s short film " The Ghost Apprentice " or else point the limitation of AI . There ’s intense public debate in Hollywood over the time to come of AI ; some are convinced this is technology to be mastered , while others believe the possibilities are exaggerated , and that it threaten prowess . I ’m no innovative - Clarence Shepard Day Jr. Luddite ; in a late career , I actually worked on technology that was fundamentally a precursor to AI . But I concede I ’m rather more sceptical than many , and very wary indeed .
That naturally imply a recent article byForbesfascinated me . Charlie Fink - a former tech executive who covers AI , XR , and the Metaverse forForbes- publish what amounts to a review of a novel AI - generate short circuit by Kavan Cardoza ( known professionally as Kavan the Kid ) . polemically , the clause bore the title"The Best Star Wars Movie In Years Is Made With AI.“I hold I was initially rather amused , because there hasn’tbeenaStar Warsmovie in old age , so there are n’t incisively a destiny of competitor … but my curiosity was offend .
“The Ghost Apprentice” Is A Tremendous Star Wars Story
This Is Better AI Than I’m Used To Seeing
I ’m sure enough not the only one to have notice that my YouTube has been absolutely packed with AI videos of recent . Most have reinforced my world-wide chariness of AI , but some of them are worth watching . “The Ghost Apprentice " is one of the best I ’ve ever seen ; the tale is a Riffian on the classic Skywalker saga , but it ’s done in a fresh and original elbow room . I wish the central amour propre , the idea of a immature Jedi Padawan who ’s been taught by theForce Ghostof his uncle , and who come out of concealing to face aSith Lord .
Forbes ' author , Charlie Fink , praises " The Ghost Apprentice " for its narration , emotional astuteness , and " the sheer technical glare of its instruction execution . " I do agree with the tale , the carrying into action is secure , and the dialog certainly has strong emotional astuteness . Fink - a university reader - apparently showed the short film to his students in a lecture hall , and his revaluation was simple:“It looked groovy . No artifact , no hallucination . If I did n’t tell you the striking visuals were made by AI , you would n’t know it . The thrill - roll in the hay storytelling was all Cardoza . "
I do n’t entirely jibe .
Without Actors, You Just Don’t Get Passion
The Emotion Isn’t Quite There
The dialogue in The Ghost Apprentice " is enormous , and the script work really well . The problem , though , is thatit all feel a little … flat . Take , for exemplar , one fictional character who ’s a pilot ; her personal line of credit have so much mouth , and you could feel the bare-ass electric potential . But the AI ca n’t deport it ; the line are passionless , and the facial expressions do n’t contain any of those microfeatures that a tangible human being demonstrates when they ’re speak . AI just about work for Jedi - it ’s an approximation of the repose sought under theJedi Code- but it does n’t for anyone else .
AI can deport bully taradiddle , but it ca n’t deliverpassion .
AI can cede great narrative , but it ca n’t deliverpassion . You necessitate actual thespian for that , performers who demonstrate something unequaled and original , rather than an AI simulation that is - by nature - derivative . This is one of the undecomposed AI - createdStar Warsstories I ’ve seen , but it still shew why AI can not make movies . AI ca n’t give real , ad-lib performances;the crude potential difference of the script still lies untapped , because only a human being can drawinspirationfrom business line on a page , create something much more transcendent .
AI Makes George Lucas' Prequel Trilogy Mistakes Even Worse
Technology Needs To Be Handled Much More Wisely
George Lucas himself views AI filmmaking as inevitable . He always loved to push the gasbag in technical term , and he ’d no doubt be pioneer the use of AI if he was require inStar Warstoday . " It ’s inevitable , " Lucas toldBrut FRin an audience at the Cannes Film Festival last year . " I mean , it ’s like saying , ' I do n’t believe these motorcar are gon na solve . lease ’s just stick with the horse cavalry . Let ’s stick with the gymnastic horse . ' And yeah , you may say that , but that is n’t the way the world works . "
Lucas is proper . But here ’s the catch ; we all know his own seek to push the bounds of science in filmmaking were not always successful . IrewatchedThe Phantom Menaceon the big screen last yr , and its lavish use of CGI has held up better than I thought ; but it ’s still odd thatthe original trilogy movies , with their pragmatic event , have senesce rather well than the prequels . Lucas overuse CGI , creating stunning environments that just did n’t quite feelreal . It ’s the same problem Lucasfilm is currently encountering with overexploitation of the Volume , ILM ’s revolutionary CGI surroundings engineering .
My best guess is that AI filmmaking will come the same pattern as the use of CGI : that some studios will initially go over - the - top in using it , creating stories that - however safe - just do n’t find grounded and real . groundbreaker will come in , just asThe Phantom Menacehas been far transcend by James Cameron’sAvatar , and they ’ll happen shipway to use it well . But there will always be a want for human beings in the production , for functioning , for actors , for intake . There ’s no removing the human ingredient , and " The Ghost Apprentice " proves that .
AI Fan Films Miss What Makes Fan Films Great
There’s So Much More To Fan Films
I can see the attraction of AI when it comes to make sports fan films . Back in 2001 , fanfic became my room access into theStar Warsfandom as a whole ; I can opine myself as a young writer , excited to deform my ideas into something solid and visual . But this is to misunderstand what a fan moving-picture show really is ; because , at heart , every production is a quislingism . When you turn a fanfic into a buff film , you ’re allow others to insert into the story , to have a say in how characters and concepts are portrayed .
The better fan films are wonderful to watch . You find yourself marvel at characterization and portrayal , at stunt carrying into action , at skillful lightsaber fighting choreography ( does n’t everyStar Warsfan really need to show what they can do with a lightsaber ? ) . Sometimes , as with the original trilogy , you may smell where budgetary restriction have made things out of the question ; on other occasions , you ’re amazed at what they ’ve manage to draw off . " How did they do that ? " you enquire yourself .
When it come to AI , though , there ’s no such sense of wonderment . You know exactly how it was create : a data processor did it . There ’s no coaction , no interpretation , only the industrial plant of a single writer brought to something that looks like " life " on a screen . As I say , I can understand the attraction ; but the bestStar Warsfan films are so much more .
Custom image by Yeider Chacon
Upcoming Star Wars Movies
Release Date
The Mandalorian & Grogu
Custom image by Debanjana Chowdhury
May 22 , 2026
