Star Trek Knows It: Captain Kirk's Death Really Did Let the Hero Down

Warning : contains freebooter forStar Trek : Lower Decks#4 !

Captain Kirk ’s demise let the iconic torpedo down – andStar Trekknows it . After a lifetime of risky venture as skipper of theEnterprise , Kirk was kill inStar Trek : generation . For geezerhood , sports fan theorize on what Kirk ’s death might actually look like , but when it finally happen , segments of fandom were outraged . While the initial anger settled , the public debate rages on , andStar Trek : Lower Decks#4 chimes in on the issue .

Ryan North has write everyStar Trek : Lower Deckscomic to date .

Star Trek : Lower Decks#4 is written by Ryan North and attract by Jack Lawrence . TheCerritosinitiated a warp bubble that circumstantially begin a chain reaction in another macrocosm that would destroy it . Two alien from that dimension come aboard the ship , seeking retaliation . Captain Freeman win over them to let the crew find a solution , but they are ineffective to do so . As Freeman tries to get back on the aliens ' good side , Mariner conjure up Captain Kirk ’s belief in a “ no - win scenario , ” saying that until he fall off a bridge , he had a just bar going .

Captain Kirk’s Death Did Not Go Over Well WithStar TrekFans

Star TrekFans Felt Kirk Deserved Better

Captain Kirk is an right-down caption both in theStar Trekuniverse and in pop culture as a whole , and fans sense this should have dictated how he die .

Captain Kirk is an out-and-out legend both in theStar Trekuniverse and in pop music culture as a whole , and buff felt this should have dictated how he exit . Kirk saved the Federation many times , be it from V’Ger , Klingons or a investigation that only talk to whale . He was an exemplary policeman who lead by example and inspired absolute confidence in his crew . He in turn inspire them , and many went on to become command officers . With his record , manyStar Trekfans felt Kirk should have died in a blaze of glory , saving the galaxy one last time .

Star Trek : Generationswas the first movie to star the cast ofStar Trek : The Next Generation .

Mariner ’s joke keeps withStar Trek : Lower Decks’gentle skewering of the franchise , but also points to an uncomfortable truth : Kirk did not get a good death . As go steady in 1994’sStar Trek : Generations , Kirk was pin in an extradimensional “ Nexus ” for 70 + years , before being rescue in the 24th century by Captain Jean - Luc Picard . The twoEnterprisecaptains team up to stop the moving picture ’s villain , Doctor Soran , from destroy a nearby planet . During the encounter , Kirk is hit by Soran ’s phaser , and he fall from a nosepiece . Captain Kirk took his last breathing spell in the front of Picard .

Yet by dying with Picard at his side , Captain Kirk managed to avoid a deep - invest care of his : that he would die alone . Kirk very much believed this would be his fate , express it several time throughout the franchise . There was no rational rationality for Kirk to think he would die alone , but it was a notion that persisted . While Captain Kirk ’s demise may not have endure up to lover expectations , he did not decease alone , which potentially claim some of the sting out of his death .

Captain Kirk’s Controversial Death Gets Called Out ByLower Decks

The Call-Out Reflects an OngoingStar TrekDebate

Captain Kirk ’s death inGenerations , while disappointing to some , was far more realistic . There is an expectation in pop culture that great hoagie like Kirk die as they endure : saving lives and bring through the world . Movies , television and literature are overabundant with examples of this trope , and many think it would apply to Captain Kirk . In the real mankind , near hoi polloi break senseless deaths . However , this is not a laid ruler , and one that solicit to be overthrow . While Kirk ’s expiry was not entirely in vain – Soran was defeated , it still felt like a huge net ball - down and was viewed as senseless by many in 1994 , and still is today .

As the Kelvin Universe is destroyed in Star Trek # 26 , Captain Kirk gets a bittersweet conclusion , one that reflects the sacrifice made by his late father .

Kirk ’s dying , while not as hotly contested today as it was over 30 year ago , is still a topic of public debate , andStar Trek : Lower Decks#4 calls this out . Mariner observe a “ no - win scenario”–a term Kirk often used . She mentions fall off the nosepiece , and her comment about his amazing run is a gentle dig at fan ’ perceptions of his death . WhileStar Trekfans uphold to consider Kirk ’s end , the dealership have a go at it he catch a bum deal .

Andor Season 2’s Continued Themes Of Sacrifice Explained By Creator & Cast: “We Should Have A Grief Counselor”