Star Trek: Section 31
One of the biggest failure ofStar Trek : Section 31is that the streamingStar Trekmovie did n’t in reality serve its biggest questions . subdivision 31 agentive role andTerran Emperor Philippa Georgiou(Michelle Yeoh ) reappearance inStar Trek : discussion section 31 , drop a line by Craig Sweeny and directed by Olatundi Osunsanmi . Georgiou ’s version of subdivision 31 inStar Trek : Discoveryis a 23rd century open secret , with its recognisable black badges . Skilled Starfleet misfit like Georgiou and Klingon deserter Ash Tyler ( Shazad Latif ) are shuffled off to Section 31 , where their gray morality makes them perfect for off - the - al-Qur’an , unethical missions .
That ’s a large change from how Section 31 is introduce inStar Trek : Deep Space Nine , as a shadowy , secret subdivision of Starfleet that no one knows about . After Dr. Julian Bashir ( Alexander Siddig ) is quietly recruited as aSection 31 agent , Captain Benjamin Sisko ( Avery Brooks ) see that Starfleet Command maintains no prescribed placement on the beingness of Section 31 . Being one of Starfleet ’s deepest , non-white secret means there ’s no one to declare the 24th century version of plane section 31 accountable . Without oversight , Section 31 has free rein to do the foul oeuvre that supposedly maintainsStar Trek ’s Sion .
One Of Star Trek: Section 31’s Biggest Failures Is Not Answering Its Biggest Question
Why Did Section 31 Change So Much Between Star Trek: Discovery And Star Trek: Deep Space Nine?
One of the biggest failure inStar Trek : Section 31is that itnever answers the head of how Section 31 went from an assailable secret inDiscoveryto an organization that does n’t officially exist inDS9 . InStar Trek : incision 31 , Starfleet’sLieutenant Rachel Garrett(Kacey Rohl ) is on the team , and Georgiou confirm Section 31 still have Starfleet ’s more problematic castoffs . Star Trek : surgical incision 31 ’s confused epoch is still operate onDiscovery - earned run average pattern , because it knows about , and possibly condones , Section 31 . The crack-up in the communications protocol that ’s destined to drive Section 31 underground has never been explain .
Star Trek : plane section 31 introduces a fresh threat to the Federation Emperor Georgiou must overcome . Here ’s what Section 31 ’s ending mean value .
Instead , Star Trek : part 31is a dissociate play that wastes the opportunity to show what made Section 31 bogus its own death inStar Trek ’s baffled Era , and paradoxically fails to show any actual spycraft . It does n’t answer if 24th - 100 mission went too far or if there was a deep conflict between Starfleet and Section 31 as an independent organization . It ’s also curious to know where Section 31’sDS9 - earned run average liberty even total from . Star Trek : Section 31never excuse the inner working of Section 31 as an espionage part , so how it became Starfleet ’s darkest secret is anyone ’s surmise .
Waiting For A Section 31 Sequel To Answer Its Biggest Star Trek Question Was A Mistake
Taking Out All The Star Trek Means A Section 31 Sequel Probably Won’t Happen
It ’s possibleStar Trek : Section 31wanted to wait until its sequel to suffice questions about how Section 31 works or why it go underground , but that ’s another big misunderstanding . alternatively of being a surprisal knock , or even a divisive debut inStar Trekcanon like its parent showStar Trek : Discovery , lover and critics alike have deemedStar Trek : part 31a failure . Even if Paramount+ makes moreStar Trekstreaming movies , aSection 31sequelprobably is n’t take place . Without a sequel on the horizon , Star Trek : Section 31leaves a passel of unanswered questions on the board .
Cutting moral philosophy or canon deep - dives fromSection 31 ’s original architectural plan — if there were any — is like trim away all theStar Trek .
Like manynewStar Trekprojects , Star Trek : Section 31had its plowshare of skeptics , so there ’s a sealed logic in wanting to wow audience with spectacle aright off the squash racquet and save crowing interrogative for after . But the bestStar Trekstories boom on big questions with complex reply , so cutting moral philosophy or canon deep - dives fromSection 31 ’s original design , if there were any , is like trimming away all theStar Trek . peradventure a serial would have been capable to answer what fall out to incision 31 , but as a movie , Star Trek : division 31doesn’t even bother ask .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
