Rebel Moon
Summary
Zack Snyder has been hyping up his R - rated director ’s cold shoulder of theRebel Moonmovies since the two - parter was first announced , but are the new versions any well than the original cuts ? When Snyder made a deal with Netflix to essentially turnHeavy Metalmagazine into a live - action moving picture , they disagreed on the valuation . Netflix wanted a PG-13 sci - fi actioner they could market to younger viewers , but Snyder want to make an R - rated movie for young grown - ups . They compromised by making both , first releasing PG-13 interlingual rendition and subsequently append them with R - rated director ’s cuts .
When the PG-13 versions were relinquish in December 2023 and April 2024,theRebel Moonfilms got eviscerated by criticsand the consultation response was tepid at best . There was hope that the R - rated director ’s cuts , which fulfilled Snyder ’s complete sight for the task , would be an improvement . Now that the director ’s cuts , dubbedRebel lunar month – Chapter One : Chalice of BloodandRebel Moon – Chapter Two : Curse of Forgiveness , have been free , it ’s time for a verdict . Are the conductor ’s slice comfortably than the original pic ?
The managing director ’s cuts of Zack Snyder ’s Rebel Moon movie are n’t just acquire a fancy new R - military rating ; they ’ve been given fancy new titles , too .
Zack Snyder’s Rebel Moon Director’s Cuts Seemed To Improve The Movies (According To Audiences)
The director’s cuts have slightly better Rotten Tomatoes scores than the originals
motion-picture show
RT Critics ' Score
RT Audience Score
Rebel Moon : Part One - A nestling of Fire
22 %
56 %
Image via Netflix
Rebel Moon : Part Two - The Scargiver
17 %
47 %
Image via Netflix
Rebel Moon - Part One : Director ’s Cut
33 %
66 %
Rebel Moon - Part Two : Director ’s Cut
68 %
According to their Rotten Tomatoes score , theRebel Moondirector ’s cutshave improved on the original versions of the moving-picture show . In its original iteration , Rebel Moon : Part One – A Child of Fireearned a blue “ stinking ” 22 % approval evaluation from critic and 56 % from audience . The director ’s cut has an ever - so - slightly upright critics ’ mark of 33 % and a warmer – even fresh – military rating of 66 % from audiences . These scores indicate thatcritics and interview both deemPart One ’s director ’s cut to be the best versionof the movie ( an supererogatory 10 % from each group ) .
The original version ofRebel Moon : Part Two – The Scargiver , on the other hand , earned an even more dreary ( and even more rotten ) critics ’ score of 17 % and a kinder audience mark of 47 % . The director ’s cut ofPart TwosharesPart One ’s critics ’ score of 33 % and has a slightly fresher audience paygrade of 68 % ( which almost voice good).Both critics and audiences gibe thatPart Two ’s director ’s cut is betterthan its predecessor , but the critic ’ grade is still fairly low . This decisive receipt suggests the director ’s cuts improve on the film – but not by much .
Snyder has plans for a trilogy of two - partRebel Moonfilms , which would amount to a aggregate of six motion picture .
Why The Critics' Reviews For The Rebel Moon Director’s Cuts Are Still Low
Just because Snyder added some gore and nudity, it didn’t magically make Rebel Moon a story worth telling
The critics ’ reviews for theRebel Moondirector ’s cuts are still pretty negative because recutting a motion picture as an gas constant - rated sex - and - violence fest does n’t as if by magic make all its fault go away . Just because Snyder has added some gore and nudity to the films , it does n’t all of a sudden makeRebel Moona story worth telling . Whether it ’s rated PG-13 or rated R , Rebel Moonis still a otiose , uninspired nothing of a narrativethat rent two movies to cover a floor that Akira Kurosawa nailed in one . It ’s derivative of innumerous better sci - fi story , fromDunetoStar WarstoHeavy Metal .
The big problem with the PG-13 version ofRebel Moonwasn’t that its sex scenes were n’t vivid enough ; it was that the characters were completely one - note . They were all based on the same stoic pilot , and they were each as underdeveloped and unengaging as the last . In the PG-13Rebel Moonmovies , the interview had no reason to care about the charactersor connect with them emotionally – andthat remains the same in the R - rated versions . It ’s scarcely surprising thatthe R - ratedRebel Moonmovieshaven’t won over critics , becausethe films ’ fundamental flaws are still there .
Why The Rebel Moon Director’s Cuts Were Better Than The Original Versions
No version of Rebel Moon is a good movie, but the director’s cuts are closer to Snyder’s original vision
Neither version ofRebel Moonis a especially good movie , but the R - rated manager ’s cutting are much close to Snyder ’s original imaginativeness . The PG-13 versions of theRebel Moonmovies offered a sanitized , watered - down reading of the history . It ’s understandable why Netflix wanted a PG-13 version , so their investment could gain a wide audience , but it ’s clear that the PG-13 versions are n’t the movies that Snyder want to make . There ’s much more spirit and passion in the director ’s cuts(even if they still order the same slothful , derivative story with the same drilling , one - note characters ) .
The PG-13 versions are perfunctory , but the radius - rated rendering are passionate . Of naturally , they ’re also much long . The PG-13 rendering were mercifully rattling , telling their stories in just over two hours . A Child of Fireran for 134 transactions andThe Scargiverran for an even more forgiving 122 minutes . The director ’s cuts , on the other hand , have runtimes like toLawrence of Arabia . Part Oneruns for a humongous 204 arcminute andPart Tworuns for a more or less less taxing , but still very foresightful 173 minute . Viewers with a short care span might struggle withRebel Moon ’s director ’s cuts .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been save
Cast
From director Zack Snyder comes Rebel Moon , a sci - fi action pic jell in the depths of space and following a dependency that is facing the threat of Regent Balisarius . Sofia Boutella play a warrior charge with recruiting others in the fight against the despot , and his unstoppable forces that are dead set on seduction .
