Band of Brothers
launch the eclat and continued popularity of the World War II miniseries , there is still the motion of , " How accurate isBand of Brothersin its depiction of these real - lifetime soldiers and the conflict they fought?“The serial is based on Stephen E. Ambrose ’s book of the same name , which compose audience , stories , and testimonies from thereal soldiers who were part of Easy Company . In this way , the accuracy ofBand of Brotherscan be attributed to the factual men who exist the events occurring on - screen .
AlthoughBand of Brothersis noted for its accuracy , it still does n’t get everything veracious . World War II buff have certainly horn in holes through the series ' uniform , weapons , and other small military detail . However , beyond the minutiae , there are also a few major fault thatBand of Brothersmade in their depiction . These mishaps are serious because of how they falsify sure characters and events or take aside from the shock of the narrative . They are both error and creative liberties that harm the integrity of the serial .
10Private Cobb’s Story Is Changed
Cobb’s Portrayal Isn’t Entirely Accurate
In the installment “ The Last Patrol , ” the serial features Private Cobb verbally assaulting Sergeant Martin . This , however , is n’t actually one of the events that led to his discharge . Instead , he physically assaulted Lieutenant Foley when inebriated . That is what led to his court - martial , butCobb did n’t really stop up assoil until after the state of war was over .
Cobb is also characterized as someone who is blistering and caustic . That ’s not how those who actually roll in the hay and served with him would categorise him though . Instead , memoirs from soldier like Private Webster suggest that Cobb was very friendly with other soldiers outside of that isolated incident .
The series also leaves out part of his religious service record . While many of the soldier discuss where they were before end up in Easy Company , it ’s never refer in the show that he fight in Operation Torch in Africa . He was with the first Armored Division there just one yr before joining Easy Company and his ship for the return key journeying was sunk by a German hoagie .
Band of Brothers is one of the all - time great TV series , but over 20 old age on , it ’s clear some things have held up well than others .
9Password Rotation Is Inaccurate
Password Rotation Was Necessary To Prevent Infiltration
There are a lot of small detail in the miniseries that could be overlooked when it comes to adjective particular . The median audience member , for example , might not agnize that salute with the left hand is a signboard of hurt even though characters use their left-hand hand in the movie as though it is normal . Some adjective item were overlooked , however , that were of import to the timeline of consequence in the movie .
For example , passwords among units were rotate out every three days after D - Day . It was a path to make certain soldiers had n’t been compromised and that if intelligence information did get out , those replace passwords would know . When Blithe encounters Speirs following D - Day , the passwords that are used in the scene are already disused . Flash - Thunger was only used on D - Day . The next three days used a unlike password , and then days four through six used another , etc . The use of goods and services of the wrong password implies the unseasonable amount of prison term passing .
8Band of Brothers Featured A German Jagdpanther In “Carentan”
The Equipment Shown In Episode 3 Would Not Have Been Used Here
The wrong vehicle or weapon being used in a war epic might not be notice by the average person . They will , however , be discover by those with an interestingness in history or the war in question .
In world , a Jagdpanther would not have appeared there
Though this detail could be categorized as a minor error in the grand outline of the serial , it ’s one that is repeated often when discuss whatBand of Brothersgot wrong about World War II . DuringBand of Brothers’Battle of Carentanin episode 3 , the counterpunch - onrush shows a Jagdpanther , a World War II armored combat vehicle destroyer , as part of the Germans ' force . In realism , a Jagdpanther would not have appeared there . The cooler were only used late in the Battle of Normandy , and to boot , the closemouthed ones at the time of Carentan were in the Germany 654th Heavy Antitank Battalion .
Custom image by SR Image Editor
7German Colonel Surrenders To Major Winters
The Real Winter Kept A Token Of The Surrender And Noted A Striking Detail
InBand of Brothers’final sequence , " point , " Major Winters has an fundamental interaction with a German soldier that was much more interesting in veridical life . On - silver screen , the unnamed German colonel offers Winters a Luger as a show of his fall . Winters tell the world to keep his sidearm , showing his respect for the enemy soldier . It ’s a way to spotlight Winters ' character .
However , the real Major Winters maintain the gun , which was a Walther PP side arm . moreover , he substantiate that the gun had never been fired during the German soldier ’s time in the state of war , a item that did n’t come along in the show . This cause the ordnance more active and symbolic . However , Band of Brothersfocused more on Winters ' respectabilitythan what the gunman rightfully meant . Adding in just one more present moment to show that the other man had never fired his gun during the warfare would have made for a more interesting reveal .
6Band Of Brothers Fails To Flesh Out Anna’s Story
The Series Cannot Serve All Supporting Players
… there are some eccentric who could have been better serve by the serial .
Even though Band of Brothers is able-bodied to get into more character detail as a series rather of a movie , there are some characters who could have been better served by the serial . Their real stories do n’t make it wholly to the screen .
In the case of Anna , run by Rebecca Okot , she ’s a Belgian nurse whose real name was Augusta Chiwy . She was really much more expansive than she appeared in the serial , having saved six offend soldiers from the infirmary bombing and perishing while trying to rescue a seventh . She did all of this despite there being a regulation for American armed forces at the metre that stipulated Black nanny were not allowed to treat white soldiers .
Custom Image by SR Editor
Rumor has it that an army Doctor of the Church talk up for her , telling soldiers that they either allowed her to treat them or they would die .
5Downplaying Malarkey’s Miraculous Story
The Truth Proved Too Unbelievable To Be Included In The Show
Part ofBand of Brothers’brilliance is the seemingly too - good - to - be - true report it order that unfold during the events of this major war . However , what happened to Easy Companywas even more marvelous but was downplayed for credibleness . For good example , Band of Brothers’Malarkey forms a Julian Bond with a German captive of state of war after realizing they grow up in the same township .
The unfeigned news report was even greater than the serial painted it as though . Malarkey and the POW did n’t just raise up in the same town ; they work across the street from each otherfor many eld before the warfare ever began . These little moments of connective avail make people realize how small the macrocosm can really be , but the audience might have check something like this as stretching the truth .
From The Liberator to Catch-22 , here are 10 War dramas similar to Band of Brothers that some fans might enjoy .
4"Unnecessary Destruction Of Property”
Some Historians Dispute Such Orders Having Existed
Sometimes , Band of Brothers’inaccuracies have nothing to do with fact but concern story and dialogue alternatively . One scene , in special , was displume apart by a World War II historiographer who claimed that the dialogue is a Hollywood ornamentation rather than a genuine scenario . In the view , an Easy Company soldier assure a British tank commanding officer to fire through a sign to get a hidden German armoured combat vehicle . However , the British soldier refuses , saying that he is prohibited from creating " unneeded destruction of belongings . "
According to the historian , this character of conversation would never have really materialize . Not only did the order to not do prop damage not survive , but British soldiers were just as likely to do wrong as American soldier . From the historiographer ’s stand , this scene is meant toportray the Americans as more " gung - ho " and " macho " whereas the British are more serene and restrained . In the destruction , this conversation is a false one that enforces stereotype and decreasesBand of Brothers’accuracy .
3Private Albert Blithe’s Fate
Blithe’s Death Took Place Decades After The Series Suggested
WhileBand of Brothers’minor change and mistakes can be jolly overlooked , some depictions were only too swell to excuse . One of these isthe fate of Private Albert Blithe . InBand of Brothersepisode 3 , Albert Blithe is introduced as a soldier struggling with shell shock absorber . He courageously overcomes his fear during the Battle of Bloody Gulch only to be shoot in the neck by a sniper day afterward . At the end of the sequence , Band of Brothersstates that Blithe finally diedfrom his injuries in 1948 . This , however , was not true .
In reality , Blithe recovered from his severe wound , which was a shot to the collarbone or shoulder rather than the neck . More than that , Blithe afterwards fight back in the Korean War where he earned a Silver Starfor valour in scrap and was promoted to the rank of Master Sergeant . He married and had two children . finally , Blithe did conk out of a perforated ulcer in 1967 , 20 year after the serial stated . The understanding for this mistake inBand of Brotherswas due to the men of Easy Company losing touch with Blithe and assuming he had become flat .
Band of Brotherswon 7 Emmy Awards in 2002 , a Golden Globe for Best Miniseries , and a Peabody Award in 2001 .
2First Lieutenant Norman Dike’s Cowardice
Dike Was A Decorated And Successful Leader
Another misrepresentation of a real World War II soldier is the portrayal ofFirst Lieutenant Norman Dike inBand of Brothers . First and first , the serial show Dike as both incompetent and a coward . In the show , Dike is supposed to lead the attack on Foy but panics under pressure , leading to the unneeded dying of his own human being . Due to his indecision , he is replace by Lieutenant Spiers and is presumed drained from a later injury .
First Lieutenant Dike was an impressive soldier
Once again , this deadly fate is wrong and worse , so is Dike ’s cowardice . In reality , First Lieutenant Dike was an impressive soldier who had successfully led several attacks , even pull in Bronze Stars in Uden and Bastogne . Though Dike did stumble during the attack on Foy , it was because he had been injured , not ill - equipped . Dike even survived the fight and pass on to serve in the Korean War as well . It seems that Dike ’s negative portrayal was mostly a originative shore leave mean to shine a luminosity on Spiers .
From Tom Hardy to Michael Fassbender , the ensemble cast of characters of HBO ’s war drama Band of Brothers was stacked with some of the estimable actors in Hollywood .
1The Date Of Hitler’s Death
The Significant Date In WWII Was Misrepresented In The Series
The most gross mistake made byBand of Brothersisthe faulty date of Hitler ’s expiry . In the ninth episode of the series , a title add-in expose that the day of the month is April 11th , 1945 . German citizen crystalize up the township while the Easy Company remembers the horrors they found , include aconcentration refugee camp theBand of Brothers’soldiers liberated .
At the conclusion of the sequence , Captain Lewis Nixon give away that Hitler took his own life . This mistake is the bad of all because of its simplicity . Hitler did not actually die until April 30 , 1945 . It ’s unreadable how this mishap occurred , but its existence sure marks down the series . All in all , even the most historically accurate serial can make major misunderstanding when it comes to dead on target event .
Truthfully , it seems most inconceivable to get every detail good and still maintain amusement economic value and dramatic flair . While some of theseBand of Brothersmistakes are more excusable than others , they all act as a reminder that even the good content can scramble to get everything accurately , but that certainly does not take away from howBand of Brotherschanged TV incessantly .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been economise
Cast
Band of Brothers narrate the dramatized story of World War II ’s " well-off " party , as they go through breeding together , participate in major wartime events in Europe , all the way until the end of the state of war .
Custom Image by SR Editor
Custom image by SR Image Editor
