Related
Summary
These 10 complaints about theStar Warsprequel trilogy have been the loudest , but not all of them are precise . The prequel trilogy is largely beloved amongStar Warsmovies and TV showsnow , but when they were first released , they were generally poorly received . In fact , although many now consider the prequels to be amongStar Wars’best movies , Star Wars : Episode III - Revenge of the Sithin particular , many of the initial complaint about the trilogy persist .
In part , complaints about the prequels stemmed from their place intheStar Warstimeline . Specifically , because the originalStar Warstrilogy had been incredibly democratic , to say the least , expectations for the prequels were almost impossibly high . Nevertheless , while some complaint about the prequels may tolerate little weightiness , others are more than legitimate .
Although Star Wars ' prequel trilogy motion picture have become beloved in the franchise , there are several things about them that still make no good sense .
10Midi-Chlorians Are Too Technical
Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
One of the biggest complaints about the prequel trilogy begin inStar Wars : Episode I - The Phantom Menacewith the introduction of midi - chlorians . The exact definition of midi - chlorians has modify over the yr in the franchise . ab initio , inThe Phantom Menace , they seemed to be an exact measurement of one ’s power in the Force . Although the definition shift over time , with midi - chlorians instead meaning someone ’s potential in the Force , The Acolytereinforced that midi - chlorians map one ’s forcefulness - sensibility .
In accession to confusion over how midi - chlorians work , though , the prequels faced considerable rebound about the midi - chlorians makingStar Warstoo ' scientific . ‘The logical argument essentially boiled down to the Force being taken from something mysterious to something biological . For the most part , this complaint is just ; the Force should be something spiritual rather than something one is comport with . However , Star Warshas find more creative with this construct over the years , make it more compelling .
9Jar Jar Binks Was Too Much
Jar Jar Binks was an extremely polarizing graphic symbol inThe Phantom Menace . Many found him to be quite pestiferous , both because of his manner of speaking and because of his at times overdone awkwardness . woefully , this angriness was debauch at the voice actor for Jar Jar , Ahmed Best , who was extremely criticise come after the release of the movie . In the true , this came down to a conclusion made by George Lucas , which was out of Best ’s hand .
Jar Jar Binks was an extremely polarizing character inThe Phantom Menace .
In part , this complaint viewers have is a misapprehension of the character;George Lucas intended Jar Jar to be for kids . After all , Lucas has always maintained thatStar Warsis a dealership for child . In that sense , Jar Jar ’s goofiness is n’t intend for grownup audience to relish . However , it ’s true that Jar Jar ’s personality and actor’s line radiation diagram do dominate some scenes inThe Phantom Menace . Either mode , though , the attacks on Ahmed Best were certainly uncalled for .
8The Story Was Too Focused On Politics
One of the major government issue audiences had with the prequel trilogy , althoughThe Phantom Menacein particular proposition , was how heavy it emphasized politics . While the original trilogy had obviously focused on the Empire , it still mainly consisted of story of heroes and included numerous thrilling natural process successiveness . The prequels also had heroes , stories of brotherhood and dearest , and first-class lightsaber fight , but it is straight that they contained importantly more political plot line .
This began inThe Phantom Menacewith the blockade on Naboo and persisted throughout the trilogy , particularly pertaining to Palpatine ’s grab for might . Although some political game did hale on a bit too long , it is still fascinating how Palpatine weaponize the Senate against the Jedi and used his position of powerfulness to organise his galactic empire . Arguably , the movies could have done away with some of these scene , but this oecumenical arc remains interesting .
7Anakin Shouldn’t Have Been A Child
This is one example of a complaint that miss the point , however . Anakin start as an innocent child was essential to the news report George Lucas was endeavor to tell . Specifically , the cataclysm of Darth Vader is meant to reveal that anyone , even the most virtuous , can turn to wickedness when put in the right condition . Anakin live tremendous harm and red ink , and it go him to a position of fear and hatred . In the end , have Anakin ’s story begin with him as a youthful son was absolutely perfect .
6The Jedi Seemed Too Flawed
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack Of The Clones
Although the Jedi seemed nearly mythical when they were described in the original trilogy , the prequels humanize them well , although that was n’t always a respectable thing . InThe Phantom Menace , it became clean that the Jedi did not always get along ; there was plentifulness of disagreement , particularly with Qui - Gon Jinn and the Jedi Council . However , the fault with the Jedi became substantially clearer inStar warfare : Episode II - Attack of the Clones .
Attack of the Clonessaw the Jedi take a inscrutable clone army in their name that they had no idea about , link a war despite their astronomic role being peacekeepers and not soldier , and act even closer with a hole-and-corner Sith Lord . For this rationality , many complain ( and continue to complain ) that the Jedi were plainly too flawed . While the Jedi were still clearly on the undecomposed side , and although complexness is more realistic , at times , this did go a footmark too far . As just one example , if the Jedi were to become soldiers , they should have done so begrudgingly .
5Obi-Wan And Anakin Don’t Share Enough Screen Time
Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith
Obi - Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker were both characters audiences were already familiar with , but the prequels intensify their popularity in the franchise . In fact , this duo inAttack of the ClonesandRevenge of the Sithbecame one of the most beloved facial expression of the prequel trilogy . It is for this cause that many were disappointed to see their limited concealment time together in the prequels .
In bothAttack of the ClonesandRevenge of the Sith , there are multiple example of Anakin and Obi - Wan parting way and going on freestanding mission , which disappoint viewers who want to see the two work together more often . This complaint is middling reasonable ; the opening scene ofRevenge of the Sithreveals how hilarious and brilliant the two were together , and it ’s a shame that this was n’t shown more often . Although this dynamic was deepened inStar Wars : The Clone Wars , that was n’t quite the same .
4The Dialogue Was Poorly Written
One of the most famous ill about the prequel trilogy is the dialogue , which audiences often ground a bit on - the - nose or overdone . This was especially dependable for Anakin Skywalker ’s lines in bothAttack of the ClonesandRevenge of the Sith . Many of these lines , including Anakin ’s comment to Padmé about not liking sand , have become very commonly used in memes and remain democratic joke in the franchise .
Once he ’d reverse to the dark side , Anakin maintained his ego but became a bit out of touch with reality .
While it ’s fair to say these line were a second heavily - handed at time , they were also for the most part lawful to Anakin ’s part . A outstanding example of this is Anakin ’s speech on Mustafar , in which he suppose he has brought peace , exemption , justice , and security to his novel Empire . Yes , that speech was highfaluting , but that ’s because of Anakin ’s mental state at the time . Once he ’d turned to the dark side , Anakin maintained his ego but became a bite out of touch with realness ; his speech reflected that .
3Padmé’s Response To The Tusken Raider Massacre Was Bewildering
One of the most shocking moment inAttack of the Cloneswas Anakin ’s brutal debacle of the Tusken Raiders , which was arguably his first Darth Vader moment . However , while that was surprising enough , Padmé ’s response was even more so . Padmé was known for being estimable and consecrated to justice , both in her part as Queen of Naboo and in the Senate . However , when she was confronted with the realness of what Anakin had done , she plainly sound out that being angry is human .
This charge is certainly warrant .
This was a wildly understate response to the ugly crime Anakin committed , and it has become a major complaint about the prequels for that reason . This ill is certainly warrant . Not only was this out of step with Padmé ’s character , but it was also such a terrible chemical reaction that it defile her double more broadly . Star Warsalso has yet to make this any better with additional circumstance , if there could be any .
2Anakin’s Fall Happened Too Quickly
The suddenness of Anakin ’s fall inRevenge of the Sithis one of the most significant issues viewers hadand continue to have with the movie . Although Anakin had a issue of moments , such as the incident with the Tusken Raiders , that discover his step toward the dreary side , the view in which he eventually turns does happen rather dead . When faced with the option between Mace Windu and Palpatine , Anakin chose Palpatine , cutting off Mace Windu ’s hand in the process .
Palpatine then kill Mace Windu , and , after a quick moment of guilty conscience and ignominy over what he had done , Anakin agreed to join Palpatine and was christened Darth Vader . Given all that had transpire , this did seem to be an odd here and now for Anakin to fully commit to the dark side , even given its connection to his fear of losing Padmé . AlthoughThe Clone Warsadded context to this second , it is true that the substitution was a bit too quick .
1The Way Padmé Died Was Confusing And Didn’t Do Her Justice
One of the largest complaints about the prequel trilogy is also one of the most valid . Many were very discomfited to see how Padmé died , even having expected her not to make it out of the prequels awake in light of the original trilogy . Specifically , Padmé break down in labor ostensibly of a broken heart . Although many other theories have been bounced around , it ’s genuine that she is simply described as having lose the will to live , which was a very dissatisfactory end to such a heroic character .
This truly was a ill service to the character Padmé was , and the complaints about her demise are more than valid . Hopefully , someday the franchise will offer a better explanation for her last . For now , though , this remains one of the most perceivable complaints about theStar Warsprequel trilogy .
